Paul O'Brian writes about Watchmen, trivia, albums, interactive fiction, and more.

>SUPERVERBOSE

Tag: 2022

An assortment of covers from some of the works reviewed in this post.

What I Read in 2022, part 3

This part of 2022 was one of the more difficult parts of my life. I spent a lot of it, when I wasn’t working or tending to my family, at my dad’s bedside with my mom. He never recovered from the stroke he’d had on the operating table, and was in no shape for the chemo or radiation treatments that might have prolonged his life, and in any case the quality of that life was not great and got worse and worse. He died on December 9.

In the meantime, I was reading comics and lots of stuff about William Blake, and also Alan Moore. The Blake and Moore reading was in service of two Watchmen Bestiary posts, one focused on Blake and one focused on Moore. As for the comics, I’d gotten through the Marvel Previews (though I jumped on each new one as I picked it up from the comic book store) and was moving on to some of the other M’s on the shelf, including various Marvels and some indie comics as well. They comforted, as always.

There are spoilers here and there. In particular I cite a major concept from Busiek and Cinar’s series The Marvels.


William Blake vs. The World

John Higgs
8.9/10 · July 28, 2022

Most of the reading associated with my Watchmen project feels like work, but this one was a pleasure. Higgs brings a fantastic humanity and an eclectic body of knowledge to his examination of Blake, and in the process renders Blake’s often bizarre expression understandable and fascinating. There are also a bunch of really relevant references, like to Moore’s Jerusalem and to the King Mob riots! Also, the writing itself is a pleasure to read. A delightful find for this part of the project.


The Cambridge Companion to William Blake

Morris Eaves, ed.
7.1/10 · September 20, 2022

In a strange twist of life, despite not having been in academia for 28 years I find myself reading an essay by David Simpson, for whom Laura and I used to house-sit. And I’ve ended up citing it in the draft of my Blake & Watchmen post! This is a collection of academic essays, most written in blessedly non-jargony and non-theory-heavy prose. They tend to vary in usefulness and enjoyability, generally staying in the 35% – 75% range, with a few stronger moments and a few sloggier passages. A good survey of scholarly viewpoints on various aspects of Blake and his work, with some occasionally interesting biographical and structural insights. Also, I felt really validated by the number of full-on Blake scholars admitting that Jerusalem is really, really hard to read.


Annotated Marvels sources

Marvel
9.2/10 · September 25, 2022

Annotated Marvels came up in my (incomplete) issue collection shortly after I’d already read it for the random Previews project — too soon to just reread. But as it happens, each of these annotated issues includes a list of sources, so I decided to read those sources in conjunction with rereading the issue, to see how Busiek & Ross wove together the history of the MU from Phil Sheldon’s viewpoint. Kind of a very pale shadow of the Watchmen project. As with the larger work, deeper knowledge of the well deepens the delight of reading. Even aside from how brilliant Busiek is at constructing a coherent history, it’s super cool to see Ross’s renderings juxtaposed with the original art. A long but pleasant journey.


Wolverine: Journey of Time

Jody Houser and Marco Itri
4.3/10 · September 25, 2022

This is like a 16 page version of those old Hostess Twinkies superhero ads, except instead of Twinkies it’s motorcycles. Silly and meaningless — what’s a little fun at one page is a total waste of time at 16.


Star Wars: The High Republic (2021)

Cavan Scott et al.
8.4/10 · October 2, 2022

An enjoyable little series, with reasonable characters + situations. Nothing that blew my socks off, but I don’t regret the time spent. It’s nice to see Jedi wrestling with moral dilemmas, and figuring out how to hold the line “for light and life.” That’s a refreshing change from the usual Jedi storyline of “struggling back from extinction.”


She-Hulk: Law and Disorder Infinity Comic

Charles Soule, Javier Pulido, and Ron Wimberly
6.7/10 · October 4, 2022

Read up to current episode (#12). So this was a pleasant, entertaining enough read up until issue #9, when somebody called Ron Wimberly takes over the art and it becomes just HIDEOUS. Everybody looks like a halfhearted attempt at cubism — neither good to look at nor thought-provoking. Wimberly completely ruins whatever goodwill the first 8 issues built up, and distracts fatally from the story. It might be worth (mildly) recommending again once he’s gone, but man, until then, AVOID.


The Marvels #11-12

Kurt Busiek & Yildiray Cinar
9.3/10 · October 5, 2022

A satisfying conclusion to the story. I really appreciated the way it addressed multiple levels of comics history at once, something Busiek is perfectly suited for. Lots of great comics metacommentary, like the Torch’s bafflement at inserting a fictional new country amongst a bunch of real countries — “How does that even WORK?” Even more, though, I loved the way it literalizes the metaphorical operation of superheroes — if Captain America is a simile by being like America, Siancong is a metaphor by BEING Siancong. That some fictional broken humans try to absorb that metaphorical power for real destruction is an apt metaphor for what some real broken humans do.


All Marvel’s Voices issues (as of 10/18/2022)

Marvel
8.5/10 · October 18, 2022

Like any anthology, let alone anthology of anthologies, this is kind of a mixed bag. But I love the basic concept of highlighting marginalized creators and marginalized characters (or at least characters from marginalized backgrounds, but there’s an awful lot of overlap.) There’s a fair amount of meh, much of it driven by the enforced shortness of the stories, but there are some gems, including a Dani/Rahne story in “Indigenous Voices” that I am going to have to track down on paper. Also, D-Man and his trans superhero support group is great, and the Iceman stories in the infinity comics do a fine job of defining Bobby Drake as a great gay superhero.


The Massive: Ninth Wave #1

Brian Wood and Garry Brown
6.3/10 · October 19, 2022

This is apparently the first issue of a prequel series to a bigger post-apocalyptic saga, none of which seems to be available online through any legit channel. I would have been interested in reading more, but I’m not going to order big books of such an unknown quantity. In any case, while I liked the art and the storytelling in this issue, I have a problem with how I’m supposed to root for the characters who poison the water supply in a major city. Like, yeah, they stick it to the man I guess, but what about the babies whose formula has to use that water?


Master of Kung Fu – Battleworld

Haden Blackman and Dalibor Talajić
8.4/10 · October 19, 2022

This was one of the many “Battleworld” series that Marvel spun up briefly as part of the big Secret Wars event in 2015. I’m on record as not caring about alternate universes, but this one had Wolfsbane in it, so of course I’m gonna buy it. Overall, the book does a creditable job of mashing together Shang-Chi and X-Men, and I did really dig Rahne’s alternate Asian self, bit player though she was. Enjoyable and, like most alternate universe stories, forgettable.


Miles Morales: Spider-Man #29

Saladin Ahmed and Chris Allen
8.8/10 · October 19, 2022

I keep hitting overlaps with Miles, but that’s fine, because this is good stuff. I had this issue on my shelf for whatever reason, so I reread it. What jumped out at me this time was the subplot about the essay Miles has to write for his scholarship application. Having it center on how he still continues to put in the work and take care of business despite all the insanity of his life feels like a great surrogate for the BIPOC experience writ large — accepting great responsibility in order to maintain any power at all.


Minor Threats #1

Patton Oswalt, Jordan Blum, and Scott Hepburn
7.3/10 · October 19, 2022

Maybe it’s just me, but after watching several seasons of The Boys and having read many deconstructions of superhero mythology (including the one I’m spending years on end writing about), this debut issue felt like it was traveling very well-trodden ground and not finding any new frontiers in it. Very good art, and some fun ideas, but overall kinda uninspired.


Miracleman #1-3

Alan Moore, Garry Leach, Mick Anglo, et al
7.9/10 · October 21, 2022

These were the Marvel reprints, which I bought a few of when they came out. Again it’s an overlap with reading I did earlier this year, but these had quite a bit of back matter, including several original Anglo stories per issue. Being very familiar by now with the Moore stuff, more of my focus went to these 1950s stories, and I ended up enjoying them more than I’d expect. I’ve already rated the Moore work on its own, so I’ll rate these here. They are silly, of course, but their silliness really helps to enrich Moore’s vision. In a way I suppose it’s a similar pleasure to what I get from Watchmen background reading.


Free Comic Book Day – Molly Danger & PrinceLess

Jamal Ingle (Molly Danger), Jeremy Whitley + Emily C. Martin (PrinceLess)
6.3/10 · October 21, 2022

Both these features are well drawn and competently told, but they feel like generic girl-power tropes to me. Like, a superhero but she’s a tween kid! And her name is Molly! But not Molly from the Runaways, this is a whole OTHER Molly, who is very similar but less specific. Or like, a medieval fairy-tale thing but the damsels kick butt instead of being in distress! They don’t need princes! They’re… PrinceLess! Neither one made me want to seek out more, so good thing it was free.


Ms. Marvel volume 1 (Issues #1-19)

G. Willow Wilson, Adrian Alphona, et al
9.7/10 · October 23, 2022

This was a reread, going through my paper issues that had been sitting on a shelf, and it was just as delightful as ever. Kamala is a fantastic character, and I love the way these stories are told — a charming mixture of humor, heart, wonder, and growth. Wilson leans into Pakistani and Muslim specificity, which works great for me as an outsider and (judging from the letters column) seems to work great for insiders as well. Alphona brings a little bit of a MAD Magazine quality to his art, which makes the pictures both fun to look at and undercuts the superhero angst of it all. But the core of these stories is Kamala and her relationships, much more than superpowers and punching. The support and the stress she gets from family, friends, super-friends, and a bad boyfriend let us see the grounded, caring kid she is, even as she’s learning to navigate it all. Very satisfying.


Ms. Marvel volume 2 (Issues #1-38)

G. Willow Wilson, Nico Leon, et al
9.5/10 · November 2, 2022

These 38 issues conclude Wilson’s run on the book, and it’s a great read. Several things stand out as impressive. First, Wilson’s ability to make participation in crossovers result in deeply significant story developments — Kamala’s part in Civil War II causes a rift with Bruno that she spends the next two years trying to heal. Speaking of which, the second impressive thing is the very well-realized supporting cast, who sometimes completely take center stage, such as at the beginning of the Teenage Wasteland storyline, and Bruno’s solo Wakanda issue. Finally, and most impressively, it’s the community that gathered around this hero, who felt seen and validated by her as girls, as kids, as brown people, as Muslims, as Pakistanis, and as brown kid Pakistani Muslim girls. That, more than anything else, made this book feel like it matters.


Mud Man

Paul Grist
8.4/10 · November 5, 2022

I picked #1 off the racks as an experiment, and enjoyed it enough that I sought out the (digital) collection of the first five issues. Unfortunately, it only lasted 8. It’s a nice start though — a classically told superhero story, with deepening intrigue and a likeable protagonist, with a pretty creative power set. I wasn’t familiar with Grist, but reading up on him it’s clear he has a fan base. Though not a big enough one to keep this book alive I guess. I thought the art was pretty enjoyable — a good 1960s Marvel vibe. I would have been happy to read more of this, but oh well.


Multiple Man (2018)

Matt Rosenberg and Andy MacDonald
8.9/10 · November 7, 2022

Jamie Madrox is such a ridiculous concept that he turns out to be unexpectedly rich in metaphor. Peter David did an A+ job exploring this in the various incarnations of X-Factor and Madrox, but Rosenberg’s take is okay too. It’s got some amount of alternate universe nonsense, but I appreciate the notion that somebody could have in them both a megalomaniac and a subverter — palace intrigue all inside the skull, except everything in Jamie’s skull gets externally manifested. Also, it did get across some of the horror of just endless copies of someone. Plus Wolfsbane is in it, so that wins some automatic points from the judges.


Peter David Grey Hulk era

Peter David et al
9.0/10 · December 2, 2023

Per recommendation from Reddit: Hulk 314-377, plus some crossovers and a Joe Fixit epilogue in Hulk 395 + 396. This was inspired by wanting to dig into the history on Joe Fixit, and taking the recommendation to read broadly for context on either side, since I enjoy Peter David’s writing so much. The Hulk was very status quo for quite a long time, and this story arc really shook a lot of things up, returning to the earliest roots of day/night transformations, gray skin, and the Rick & Rosses supporting cast. It starts with John Byrne, moves into Al Milgrom, and then gets wild once Peter David shows up. We get some early work from big 90s-era artists like Larsen and McFarlane, and explore the possibilities of finding more parts in Banner, and more incarnations to go with them. I don’t know that he’ll ever be my favorite character, but these comics were certainly worth reading, and brought a psychological depth to the stories that they’d been crying out for.


Magic Words: The Extraordinary Life of Alan Moore

Lance Parkin
9.5/10 · December 4, 2023

A biographer of Moore has a bit of a tightrope to walk, since one would want to remain on his good side, but that’s not always so easy to do. Lance Parkin does quite a respectable job of treating his subject lovingly but fairly, including the more controversial bits, and he does so by rooting his analysis in Moore’s Northampton roots, over and over again. As a result, this book pairs quite well with Jerusalem — just revisiting a page of it after reading ~600 pages of the novel lit up lots of connections between Moore’s life as he’s described it and this enormous magnum opus I’m traversing. Excellent research material, and a pleasure to read as well.


The Multiversity: The Deluxe Edition

Grant Morrison et al
7.8/10 · December 12, 2023

So this is Grant Morrison being insistently, relentlessly, sometimes tiresomely and sometimes awesomely bonkers. Just bonkers at an earsplitting volume. Tons of meta, tons of “wha…?”, tons of parody and commentary, some of it clever, some of it stupid, some of it so on-the-nose that it smashes the nose right into the face. I picked it up because it has a Watchmen-esque chapter which is basically all of the above, in a mean-spirited way more often than I wanted it to be. Partly it didn’t connect with me because I lack the deep roots in DC continuity, but partly it didn’t connect with me because it’s a little too navel-gazing to really connect with a reader. Parts of it were really fun, and that made the other parts worth wading through.


New Avengers #1-14 + Infinity event

Jonathan Hickman, et al
5.6/10 · December 28, 2023

I’m not sure I read the original Illuminati story arc(s), but my understanding is that it’s about hubris. A bunch of guys who think they’re the smartest ones in the world decide that they should start making decisions unilaterally — like shooting the Hulk into space — and they end up paying dearly for that. Hickman’s premise, I guess, is that these guys have learned nothing from that experience, nor from Civil War, so what we get is yet another retread of arrogant “geniuses” behaving like a conspiracy that thinks it’s a meritocracy, in the face of a seemingly world-ending threat, like this is the first time that’s ever happened. Did I mention these are alleged superheroes we’re talking about? I covered some of this ground earlier in a read of Hickman Avengers v4, and my opinion hasn’t changed. Everybody’s acting way out of character, and the whole thing seems quite overrated to me.

An assortment of covers from some of the works reviewed in this post.

What I Read in 2022, part 2

By mid-2022, my formerly gigantic stack of Marvel Previews books was dwindling, and I was approaching, if not the present, the not-too-distant past. For years, whatever page I would select would reliably turn up a series that had ended, because these days, comic book series reliably end. But now I was getting a hold of series that were still ongoing, which led to some oddly truncated reading experiences — I tried to evaluate them for what they were and what they could give at the time.

Meanwhile, my project reading had hit a very difficult mogul: reading 400 pages reproducing William Blake’s original plates. Songs of Innocence and Experience aside, this stuff is challenging reading in any form, so it took months, even when I devoted lots of time to it. Of course, some of that time was sitting around hospital waiting rooms before and after my dad’s brain surgery, where a stroke paralyzed him and left him bedridden for the rest of his life. I was particularly grateful for the fun reading. That includes Alan Moore’s Miracleman series, which I decided I needed as background.

There are spoilers ahoy — not that I seek them out, but neither do I avoid them.


Hawkeye: Kate Bishop (2021) #1-3

Marieke Nijkamp and Enid Balam
8.7/10 · May 12, 2022

Now this is more like it. Reminiscent of (but not really equal to) the Hawkeye book, with fun mysteries, wonderful character development, clever storytelling devices, and snappy dialogue. Also trick arrows, yeah. Unlike the Star Wars and Hulk series, this totally left me wanting more. Well, except for the art, which was pretty hideous.


Black Panther (2021) #1-3

John Ridley and Juann Cabal
8.7/10 · May 14, 2022

Once again, I’ve tapped into a title that has only just started on MU, thanks to my Previews issues finally catching up with present day. This seems like an interesting enough restart for Black Panther — I’m sure it’s quite a challenge to follow Ta-Nehisi Coates’ run on the book. The plotline plausibly grows from what’s come before, and I’d be happy to keep reading… if there were more to read.


Ka-Zar: Lord of the Savage Land (2021) #1-5

Zac Thompson and Germán García
8.9/10 · May 14, 2022

So the #1 job of this series was to resurrect Ka-Zar after he was killed in the Empyre event. This was done by having the spirit of the Savage Land bring him back as its protector, just as had previously happened with Shanna. A lovely side effect of this was to separate him from his colonialist origins by making him truly one with the land. Now he can transform into aspects of the Savage Land by experiencing deep empathy with them — the very “going native” that colonialists dreaded. Ka-Zar was never my favorite character, but this was a good move forward for him and a well-crafted story overall.


Tech-On Avengers #1-6

Jim Zub and Jeffrey “Chamba” Cruz
5.9/10 · May 20, 2022

So, this is apparently a mash-up of superhero comics and some manga/anime subgenre called sentai, in which various people use cool tech to get superpowers, a la Power Rangers. So in this book the Red Skull uses some cosmic macguffin to depower every superhero, and then Tony Stark builds them all super suits to be all mech-y. It is clearly aimed at a) young readers, and b) fans of sentai. I am neither, and didn’t find a whole lot for me in this book, so for me it was a miss. Not an aggravating experience like a Cates book, but a miss nevertheless.


Legends: Black Panther (2021) #1-3

Tochi Onyebuchi et al
8.0/10 · May 20, 2022

The purpose here is to retell BP’s origin in a long enough format that it can make a slim trade. Fair enough — it’s written well, with some nice African awareness. The art is more variable, some being a bit rushed and sketchy for my taste. Kind of an average enjoyable read — nothing special but pleasant enough.


Miles Morales: Spider-Man #24-34

Saladin Ahmed et al
8.8/10 · May 21, 2022

I’ve now reached the point with this project where the Previews I’m looking at are posting issues that aren’t on MU yet. Wow! In this case, the issue at hand is MM:SM #36, whereas MU is only up to #34. My decision in this case is to read the relevant run up to that point, but complicating matters is the fact that I’ve actually already read this run up to #25 in my 100 issues of MM read. So in this case I started at the beginning of the relevant arc, then read up to MU current. This is still a quality run, and and this read happened to encompass a fun 10th anniversary issue which included fun stories from Lord & Miller + Cody Ziglar. Good times!


The Death of Doctor Strange

Jed MacKay, Lee Garbett, and Antonio Fabela
9.2/10 · May 21, 2022

This is one of those “vintage character in modern continuity” riffs, like the time-traveling young X-Men. But where that storyline contrasted modern mutant darkness with its more lighthearted beginnings, this time it’s Strange who has lightened up over time. His severe Ditko 60s “Master of Black Magic” self gets projected into the future to hang out with a kind-hearted ghost dog, workaday Avengers, and estranged Clea. It’s done in a fun way, with a murder mystery motif and a status change to make Clea Sorcerer Supreme. (As it happens, my random method dialed up Strange #2, a series which hasn’t started yet on MU, so I dialed back to this one, which MacKay used to set up the current series.) Enjoyable!


Miracleman Book 1: A Dream of Flying

Alan Moore, Garry Leach, and Alan Davis
9.7/10 · May 22, 2022

I’m taking another run at reading Miracleman — all of it this time — so I reread this first book. This time I couldn’t help but have an eye towards the “The Tyger”, since I’m at a Blake point in my Watchmen project. As it happens, there’s a prominent and repeated tiger metaphor — in Kid Miracleman’s predatory eyes. Something to be done with that, perhaps…


Miracleman Book 2: The Red King’s Gambit

Alan Moore, Alan Davis, Chuck Austen, et al.
9.7/10 · May 22, 2022

Moore continues his relentless and rather grim redemption of the ludicrous here, working out the implications of juxtaposing Shazam tropes with a contemporary 80s milieu in a pretty merciless way. Where the first volume centered on Kid Miracleman, this one centers on Miracleman’s Kid, or rather how it emerges as the lodestone for the plan that created MM in the first place. I loved the dream-fighting scenes, predictably, and the climactic scene of a superhero lifting his human enemy into space and dropping him is… something you wouldn’t see in a Silver Age book, that’s for sure. Moore invented this entire register, and it holds up damn well. There’s also some very fun supplemental material — I particularly enjoyed the framing sequence with cat yronwode breaking the 4th wall and admitting upfront the disastrous reason why the book was suddenly breaking into reprints.


Miracleman Book 3: Olympus

Alan Moore and John Totleben
9.7/10 · May 28, 2022

A foreshadowing of “Super-powers and the Superpowers” — this feels to me like a parable of international relations. On the one side there is the absolute horror of Kid Miracleman — essentially a Holocaust — and on the other side there are the Allies, led by Miracleman. Each one is trying to shape the world in its own image, and the Allies succeed, but at the cost of suppressing dissent, increasing distance from humanity, and endless grief over the bloodshed that they didn’t prevent. A beautiful ending to this excellent series.


Star Wars: Halcyon Legacy #1

Ethan Sacks and Will Sliney
8.1/10 · May 28, 2022

A fun swashbuckling debut issue that hews to the strengths of Star Wars — putting 19th and early 20th century adventure tropes into a space/sci-fi context. Nothing especially new, but enjoyable enough.


Iron Fist: Heart of the Dragon

Larry Hama and Dave Wachter
9.0/10 · May 30, 2022

Sometimes legacy creators coming back to characters with whom they’re closely associated can feel tired or byzantine, but I really enjoyed this Hama miniseries. It clearly pulls in a bunch of stuff from recent Iron Fist lore that I haven’t read — I never did catch up with any of that Brubaker/Fraction/Aja stuff. There’s a little girl, a little old dude, various Iron Fists from other… times? realities? Whatever. The tone was a lovely mix of sacred and silly, the action was exciting, the villain was credible, and seeing Okoye all Iron-Fisted was cool from both a visual and a story standpoint. And it ends with Danny getting depowered! This has apparently made way for a new Iron Fist who is actually Chinese. Cool developments!


X-Men Legends #1-11

Marvel
8.7/10 · May 30, 2022

There are a lot of ups and downs in the X-Men franchise, so when the point of a series is to bring back old creators and tell stories set sometime in previous continuity, the results are obviously going to be all over the place. Louise Simonson and Fabian Nicieza? Still not my favorites. Larry Hama on Wolverine is a pretty good time though. But what gets me in the door is Peter David on my favorite era of X-Factor. More Wolfsbane stories? YES PLEASE.


Marvel Rising (2018 4-part series)

Ryan North, G. Willow Wilson, Devin Grayson, Irene Strychalski, and Ramon Bachs
8.3/10 · June 5, 2022

So, obviously the best thing about this is another issue of Ryan North Squirrel Girl. Second best thing is another issue of G. Willow Wilson Ms. Marvel. Which must mean that Devin Grayson is the worst thing about it. While North and Wilson are solid as always, the piece overall has a real “adults writing for kids” vibe. “Let’s do one about those video games the kids love so much! Like the Donkey Kong! I used to love the Donkey Kong!” Our villain can make video games come to life, except the twist is that she’s really a good kid who got misled by an online friend. “Watch out for those randos online, kids! They could turn out to be supervillains!”


Share Your Universe sampler

Eugene Son, Nuno Plati, Christos Gage, Chris Jones, Fred Van Lente, and James Cordeiro
7.0/10 · June 5, 2022

This is clearly aimed at younger readers — everybody’s a kid or a wholesome adult. I certainly prefer it to things like Hickman’s Avengers where everyone is awful, but I’m pretty clearly not the target audience either. It was fine for what it was.


Marvel Tales: Annihilation

Mark Gruenwald, Ralph Macchio, John Byrne, Steve Gerber, Don Heck, Danny Fingeroth, and Mike Manley
7.6/10 · June 5, 2022

Collecting Marvel Two-In-One #53, Daredevil #105, and Darkhawk #6. This was a tie-in to the Annihilation Scourge event, which I read in June 2021 and concluded was pretty weak sauce. This compilation issue has as little reason for existing as the event did, and even the issues it compiles are a strange lot. You can’t really go wrong with Gruenwald/Macchio/Byrne MTIO, but Gerber’s Daredevil is odd even for Gerber. Of all the titles to go cosmic with… Daredevil? Then there’s Darkhawk, who frankly I never had the time of day for and still don’t.


Marvel Team-Up (2019)

Eve L. Ewing, Joey Vazquez, Moy R., Clint McElroy, and Ig Guara
7.2/10 · June 6, 2022

I was so excited to see a new Marvel Team-Up series announced, and signed up for it right away at the comic book store. The result was a disappointment though. The reason I loved the original MTU was that it was like a monthly Spider-Man book with a guaranteed monthly random surprise hero. I loved being able to visit all those different corners of the Marvel Universe without having to buy a boatload of books. This, though, was pretty much a 3-issue arc of Spider-Man + Ms. Marvel, then a 3-issue arc of Ms. Marvel and Captain Marvel. Surprises, not so much. Also, this is another one that feels like it’s writing down to its audience. I’m partial to the era where comic book writers were trying to elevate the form rather than water it down.


The Complete Illuminated Books

William Blake
5.7/10 · June 19, 2022

I love the idea of this book. And some things about the reality are amazing. The plates are absolutely the right way to read Blake, though far from the easiest. His words and images are intended to be taken together, and extricating one from the other does violence to both. And some of the reproductions are absolutely breathtaking. That said, there are some real downsides to this tome. First of all, it is gigantic and heavy, which — fair enough — is a result of like 400 quality reproductions bound together, but some of the reproductions are tiny!

Songs of Innocence and Experience in particular is deeply disappointing — postage-stamp reprints that require a magnifying glass to read. I guess they’re accurate to-scale reproductions, but why on earth would we favor that over readability? Beyond that, there’s the fact that a lot of this is just difficult material no matter how it’s presented. Much of Blake’s prophetic stuff has a bonkers Unabomber vibe, at least to me. Looking forward to William Blake Vs. The World illuminating it for me.


Marvel 2-In-One + Annual #1

Chip Zdarsky et al
8.9/10 · June 20, 2022

Like the Marvel Team-Up reboot, this series strayed from the premise of the original by only pairing the Thing with FF members, and making the first 10 of those the Torch. Also, a whole bunch of it was multiverse stuff with all the standard ingredients of switching alignments, dystopia, etc. That said, there were a few things that elevated it. First, Zdarsky is a strong writer, and I don’t think I’ve read anything of his I didn’t enjoy. He is one of the few I trust with “What If?” scenarios, especially based on his real-time Spider-Man series. Second, and related, is the fact that this series does lovely character work with Ben and Johnny, and even Doctor Doom. They are circling well-traced spirals, but it feels real and emotionally grounded. Finally, this is the series that brought the real FF back from limbo! How could I not love it at least a little, just for that?


Marvel Universe Avengers and Ultimate Spider-Man

Slott, Templeton, Yost, and Jones
8.4/10 · June 20, 2022

Promo comics advertising 10-year-old cartoons. Based on that premise, they’re better than they need to be, thanks to the good writers assigned to them. Still, a trifle.


The Marvels #1-10

Kurt Busiek and Yildiray Cinar
9.5/10 · June 25, 2022

Where Marvels was Busiek showing the Marvel Universe from a unique point-of-view, and implicating political issues in the process, this series foregrounds the politics and switches among many points of view to give us a healthy diversity of perspectives on the issues. All of it is enriched by Busiek’s beautiful saturation of MU lore — there are tons of delightful Easter eggs to be found by a reader like me, who has spent a long time immersed in that lore. This series is still ongoing, so I’m only reviewing the first 10 issues here, but so far I’m really digging the intertwined stories, time-jumping, varied viewpoints, and exploration of how our wars affect both our targets and ourselves.


An assortment of covers from some of the works reviewed in this post.

What I Read in 2022, part 1

The “random page outta Marvel Previews” Marvel Unlimited project continued apace as 2022 opened, taking me all over Marvel history and characters in a pretty enjoyable way (except when it told me to read Donny Cates.) During this period, I was researching a Watchmen Bestiary article on William Paley’s argument from design, so there was background reading for that dropped in there too.

Spoilers? Yes, probably. Mild ones, generally, but proceed at your own risk of spoilage.


The Watch On The Heath: Science and Religion Before Darwin

Keith Thomson
8.3/10 · January 6, 2022

This was an entertaining high-level survey of a moment in time, where what we would end up calling “science” was colliding with centuries of religious tradition, reaching a breaking point where one could really no longer accommodate the other. Along with good, clear summaries of both Darwin’s thinking and the countervailing ideas of the time, it touches lightly and enjoyably on the personalities and relationships of a whole bunch of players at this moment in history as they struggle to reconcile things like the fossil record with the literal reading of Genesis that had been accepted as divine truth for so long. Reading it was more work than pleasure for me, but for work, it was a lot of fun.


~100 issues of Mockingbird

Marvel
7.7/10 · January 18, 2022

This reading turned out to be very timely, as the MCU Hawkeye show ended up very strongly hinting that Laura Barton is “Agent 19”, which was Mockingbird’s agent number in the comics. Problem is, there’s already a Bobbi Morse in the MCU, though she was never called Agent 19. (Nor Mockingbird, not that Laura Barton was either.) This messy situation is actually pretty in keeping with the character — as CBR points out, Mockingbird’s earliest comic appearances were a mess too. She only settled into her superhero identity in Marvel Team-Up #95, after a bunch of weird Ka-Zar stuff and a false start as “Huntress.” Then very shortly she became Hawkeye’s wife, and ended up in the West Coast Avengers as his, well, adjunct I guess. She has a cool look, but her power set seems like it comes down to acrobatics and “battle staves” — a pretty thin gimmick. She gets some character development eventually when she kills a creeper without Hawkeye knowing, but overall these first 100 issues are fairly weak sauce.


~33 issues of Deathlok

Marvel
6.7/10 · January 24, 2022

Deathlok was always one of those characters who hovered on the edge of my consciousness and understanding, in a “what’s the deal with this guy?” kind of way. Turns out there have been many Deathloks, so I had good reason to be confused. I was surprised how few appearances the original had, so much so that he’s really not even considered the “main” Deathlok anymore. Well now I’ve read all those original appearances, and I kind of feel like there’s less than meets the eye. His first stories were kind of standard-issue 1970s futuristic dystopia — it’s the 1990s and cyborgs have taken over! — and kind of a mess narratively, with various twists introduced that either get dropped, truncated, or wrenched in another direction entirely.

Deathlok finally ends up getting shunted through the dimensions to land in Marvel 616, where he has a few appearances each decade. (In the actual 1990s he had long hair and a tattered trenchcoat, because the actual 1990s really were a dystopia, at least when it came to most Marvel comics.) Stories never really rose above the level of “just okay”, and always felt fairly incoherent. Plus, boy oh boy was it (apparently) hard to hand-draw computer lettering back in the 70s.


Captain America Epic Collection #10 – Of Monsters and Men (Marvel Unlimited equivalent)

J.M. DeMatteis, David Anthony Kraft, Mike Zeck
9/10 · February 3, 2022

DeMatteis and Zeck were a great combination on Captain America, with Zeck providing a classic (and ever-so-slightly cartoony) style, which DeMatteis deepened with strong character development and an exploration of philosophy and ideals. I particularly enjoyed how JMDM engaged with the less shopworn elements of Cap’s past, such as the various “substitute Caps” who emerged while Steve was in the ice. Also, though he doesn’t make a big deal of it, he strengthens the supporting cast with a gay best friend (Arnie Roth) while giving prominent roles to his Jewish girlfriend (Bernie Rosenthal) and Black ex-partner (Sam Wilson). A welcome and righteous commitment to diverse viewpoints, especially for the early 80s.


Venom Epic Collection #1 – Symbiosis (Marvel Unlimited equivalent)

David Michelinie, Todd McFarlane, Erik Larsen, et al
7.4/10 · February 14, 2022

Venom is very far from my favorite character, but this collection is about as enjoyable as a Venom book could get for me, because most of it portrays him as a villain rather than the verrry 90’s anti-hero he ended up becoming. In fact, much like I stumbled into the first Elektra issue as a kid, I also seem to own the first Spider-Man issue where he discovers that his new “costume” is a symbiote. This is a cool idea in itself, and even having it combine with someone who hates Spidey (though his reasoning doesn’t have to be QUITE so thin) is good. It’s just that from there, we end up tipping over into “gross and scary monster kills people and stuff but you should root for him! Because, um…”


The Blind Watchmaker

Richard Dawkins
9.1/10 · February 20, 2022

This book emerged in 1986, and was almost certainly the inspiration for Moore’s watchmaker references in Chapter 4 of Watchmen. It’s an excellent, patient, convincing explanation of evolution via natural selection, at least as it was understood in 1986. Like Paley before him, Dawkins makes great use of analogies to reinforce and explicate his point, except Dawkins’ analogies are a) meant to deny creationism rather than support it, and b) based in the technology of HIS day, often 80s-era computers, such as when he compares “fossil” genes to “deleted” data on a floppy disk. Still persuasive, and still a pleasure to read, 35 years later.


Thor Epic Collection #19 – The Thor War (Marvel Unlimited equivalent)

Tom DeFalco, Ron Frenz, Pat Oliffe, et al
8.9/10 · February 21, 2022

Thor was never one of my favorite characters, because he seemed so uber-powerful and above-it-all. I like the notion of comics as modern mythology, but Thor seems a little on the nose. Finding out that Don Blake was never really an actual person removed him even further from humanity. In this arc, DeFalco gives the Thor identity to a member of the supporting cast, Eric Masterson, and thereby makes the Thor book an inquiry into Impostor Syndrome. This was pretty intriguing to me, especially in light of the way that Thor starts having Spider-Man-esque problems of his secret identity screwing up his personal life. It’s also amusing to see all the various godly Asgardians get frustrated with Masterson’s ineptitude.


Spider-Man: Bloodline [Issues 1-5 of Spider-Man (2019)]

J. J. Abrams, Henry Abrams, Sara Pichelli
5.5/10 · February 21, 2022

Sooo… this is yet another iteration of an alternate universe where a bunch of the heroes we know die or somehow check out, and new heroes have to arise. This is a very shopworn concept by now, and this series doesn’t do anything inspiring with it. Peter Parker acts pretty out of character (I can believe he would abandon being Spidey, as he does periodically, but abandon his child? For 10 years? This is a guy fundamentally driven by responsibility, so no.), and aside from a few dead Avengers accounted for, the other bazillion heroes of the MU are MIA without explanation, as are the villains. It seems to me that with Spider-Man and the Avengers off the board, lots of moves would happen on both the villain and hero sides, and we hear about none of these. The Abramses introduce a good villain, and the story is reasonably well told for what it is, but nothing made me care, and nothing made much sense.


X-Men (2019) #17-21

Jonathan Hickman, et al
9.2/10 · February 22, 2022

So, I’m not at all caught up on all the “Whatever Of X” series that have changed the status quo of the X-Men in the MU, but here’s what I gather: They live on Krakoa (and have made friends with Krakoa.) Some kind of Krakoan magic allows them to resurrect mutants whenever one dies. Prof X and Magneto are in charge. Things are pretty good for mutants overall. Hickman leaves the extended soap-opera format behind in this iteration of the book, instead telling compact sci-fi/superhero tales with a rotating cast of characters, taking liberal advantage of the resurrect button. There’s a space opera, a timebending odyssey, a time/space heist, etc. It’s pretty fun! Hickman dials down the persecution and gives the X-Men a great swagger, a pleasant change of pace for the book. I only read a few issues, and they were part of a GIGANAMOUS arc that I don’t really understand, but I enjoyed them.


Avengers by Jonathan Hickman vol 4 (Marvel Unlimited equivalent)

Jonathan Hickman, et al
5.9/10 · February 28, 2022

Avengers (2012) #24-34 and New Avengers (2013) #13-23. It was interesting to read this right on the heels of some of Hickman’s X-Men work. Where the X-Men stuff was bright and wild, these Avengers stories were grim, sad, and ugly. Dr. Strange selling his soul, Iron Man creating a planet-killing device, Black Panther being super-nationalist, Mr. Fantastic being the shitty caricature that anti-FF people think he is. It’s a retread of the Illuminati idea, which was good the first time but of course is not going to go well if we treat the characters like they’ve learned nothing.

On the one hand, Hickman is again taking the premise and writing pretty much straight sci-fi out of it, but in jarring the premise out of its accustomed track, everybody felt wildly out of character — bad where they should be good, dumb where they should be smart, petty where they should be generous. I know Hickman has a ton of cred, and maybe I’m missing something awesome about this work, but I read 22 issues’ worth and did not feel enriched by it.


Avengers Academy #21-39

Christos Gage, et al
9/10 · March 5, 2022

So this feels about as close as we get to a New Mutants book on the Avengers side of Marvel, and I really enjoyed it. Gage does a lovely job of mixing mayhem with genuinely moving emotional beats, such as Juston’s relationship with his Sentinel, Lightspeed comforting Striker over his childhood trauma, and Hazmat/Mettle’s sexual & romantic frustration. Also, Gage really engages his community via the letters page, and facilitates some civil and interesting debates on what’s fair game in a comic, and what are the most effective ways to portray difficult topics.


Incredible Hercules #121-137

Greg Pak, Fred Van Lente, et al
9.1/10 · March 13, 2022

This series was great fun, and seriously engaged with Greek mythology, beautifully blending Herc’s classical exploits with his adventures in the Marvel Universe. This is a guy who can very easily become a caricature, but the writing grounds him well. It feels a little less justified in its title when it focuses on Amadeus Cho for entire issues, but the explicit shout-outs to Joseph Campbell help. I wasn’t along for the ride with Cho, so this is my first time reading much of him in his pre-Hulk form, and to be honest I tended to miss Herc when he wasn’t around. However, by far the BEST thing about this series is that it uses sound effects better than any comic I’ve seen. When hunky Thor (dressed as Herc) strikes the ground, the sound is WHATAMANNNN! When Herc punches Thor unexpectedly, the sound is sukkaPUNCH! And so on. At one point, Herc crashes into something with the sound effect “BOSCH!”, at which point I realized, yep, he’s fighting inside a Bosch painting.


Silk (2021) #1-5

Maurene Goo & Takeshi Miazawa
8.3/10 · March 17, 2022

This is straight-ahead superhero storytelling, albeit with a bit of extra millennial snark & tech. Pretty much the same mold as Peter Parker & Clark Kent — intrepid reporter investigates stuff then punches it later in superhero clothes. The character doesn’t really fascinate me, though the representation is nice. The art was pretty sketchy (er, sketch-like) overall, though there were some cool choices, e.g the penthouse elevator button bloodied by the cat demon’s finger. Pretty much a pleasant, lightweight, un-memorable read.


Natural Theology

William Paley
5.3/10 · April 4, 2022

I mean, obviously I disagree with the premise, and from this historical vantage point (especially after reading The Blind Watchmaker), it’s easy to see where Paley’s reasoning goes off the rails. But it is a pretty charming book at times. As I said in my Watchmen essay, his reaction to the natural world and mine to Watchmen are the same: an intense aesthetic rapture, followed by the desire to inventory and analyze. When he gets into arguing for the goodness of God, he’s on shakier ground, especially when he grounds that goodness in how good the privileged have it. Certainly more work than fun to read, but not as tedious as it could have been, and still thought provoking after all these years, even if most of the thoughts are about how wrong it is.


Morbius Epic Collection #2: The End of a Living Vampire (Marvel Unlimited equivalent)

Marvel
7.7/10 · April 9, 2022

(Marvel Unlimited equivalent: Fear #27-31, Marvel Premiere #28, Marvel Two-In-One #15, Spectacular Spider-Man #6-8 and #38, Savage She-Hulk #9-12, Vampire Tales #9-11 and annual #1, Marvel Preview #8) Morbius feels to me like a byproduct of the 1970s loosening of the comic code, so that monsters were allowed back in comics again. Suddenly there was this big artificial spurt of vampires, werewolves, zombies, etc. Morbius, not being undead, felt safe enough to appear in a Spider-Man book aimed (at least in part) at kids. They tried him out in formats ranging from adult black-and-white to shiny She-Hulk and Spider-Man, but he’s kind of a limited character, so in the end he was “cured” and abandoned. At least for a while. Anyway, vampire creepshow (or antihero) isn’t really my thing, so this was Mor than enough Morbius for me.


The Amazing Spider-Man Omnibus Vol. 5 (Marvel Unlimited equivalent)

Gerry Conway, Len Wein, Ross Andru, and Gil Kane et al
9.3/10 · April 21, 2022

[Marvel Unlimited equivalent: Amazing Spider-Man (1963) #143-180, annual #10-11, and Nova (1976) #12] So, this starts out with the seeds of the damned clone saga, which was dopey the first time around. That’s its downside. Its upside is a mountain-sized helping of rollicking adventure, with lots of delightful Bronze Age high-flying heroics and humor. This was a time when the original Lee/Ditko issues were a living trunk from which new story possibilities kept branching, creating a dramatic unity that still feels satisfying. Even the clone stuff gets its emotional weight from the fact that Gwen is DEAD for real. I loved touches like Spidey forced to team up with Doc Ock, or having to weigh whether he objected to the villain, the Punisher, or JJJ the most. Good supporting cast stuff too, like Harry and Liz getting together, Aunt May becoming a Grey Panther activist, and MJ sorting out her place in Peter’s life.


Daredevil (2019) #31-36

Chip Zdarsky et al.
8.9/10 · April 23, 2022

I’ve skipped over a lot of Daredevil continuity to read these contemporary issues, and a lot of it feels pretty familiar. The same characters doing the same dances — Matthew, Elektra, Kingpin, Bullseye. Daredevil’s identity teetering on revelation again, Daredevil in prison again, somebody else taking the DD identity in Hell’s kitchen again. But I do enjoy Zdarsky. He’s a skilled and compelling writer, so watching the dances and variations is still a pleasure, and I still believe in the emotional reality of the characters.


Dr. Strange Epic Collection #9 – The Vampiric Verses (Marvel Unlimited equivalent)

Roy & Dann Thomas et al.
8.4/10 · May 7, 2022

[Marvel Unlimited equivalent: Doctor Strange, Sorcerer Supreme #14-33 and Ghost Rider (1990) #12]. By Roy & Dann Thomas et al. We’re edging into the 90s here with the Doc, and the art is starting to get embarrassing. Lots of cheesecakey shots of women, a whole harem of whom seem to be fawning and fighting over Strange. Counterbalancing this, though, is Roy Thomas, as old-school as it’s possible for a Marvel writer to be, constantly calling back to Silver Age and even Golden Age characters and tropes. The result is writing that sustains pleasure even when the art provokes winces. There are also very fun lore-heavy extras at the end of many issues, detailing stuff about the Darkhold, or vampires, or voodoo, or werewolves, or what-have-you. These are Thomas at his nerd-scholarly best, almost like OHOTMU articles written in Dr. Strange’s voice.


Fantastic Four (2018) #35-39

Dan Slott et al.
9.5/10 · May 7, 2022

I’m so relieved to have my beloved FF in Slott’s hands. I’ve got this whole run collected to read in physical form, but it was fun to get a little preview of it here, starting with an anniversary issue that very cleverly uses Kang to revisit various points in FF history. It’s the ongoing story that grabs me even more, though. In some places, Slott is rearranging familiar tropes — e.g. making Johnny an uncontrollable monster instead of Ben — but in other places he’s doing more interesting work. I love the idea of Franklin in therapy for all the fricking trauma he’s endured as a kid, and that his teen self is drowning trying to live up to the various versions of him we’ve seen over the years. What a brilliant take. Oh, and hats off to using Trauma as the therapist. Great Marvel deep cut. Also, Reed saying, “Our love for you is a universal constant.” That’s MY Reed Richards.


Way of X #1-5

Si Spurrier and Bob Quinn
9/10 · May 10, 2022

So it seems clear that, at least in part, the whole Krakoa storyline for the X-Men is meant to actualize the marketplace fact that none of them can really die. By bringing that fact into the light in the fictional universe, the writers get to explore some pretty fascinating metaphysics, and Nightcrawler is the perfect character to take point on that. (Well, Wolfsbane would be the perfect character, but again marketplace realities rule.) I really enjoyed this series as our way of working through the psychological effects of removing death, of how those social changes would affect Kurt, and of how something sinister is able to creep up through the edges. The idea that Xavier and Magneto are in charge of this utopia and that where they are, so must also be Onslaught, begins to nibble at redemption for some of the worst 90s crimes.


Star Wars: The High Republic – Trail of Shadows #1-4

Daniel Jose Older and Dave Wachter
7.8/10 · May 12, 2022

I’ve been pursuing this “Marvel Previews Unlimited” project for almost three years now, and I’m finally getting to the point where I’m actually catching up with current comics. This limited series came up on the wheel, but I can’t finish it because its final issue isn’t on MU yet. In this particular case, that’s not a horrible loss, because although this series is enjoyable enough, I’m not enough of a gung ho Star Wars fan to be super curious about it. One thing I do like about the Star Wars comics, though, is that they can tell different kinds of stories in that universe, vs. the very repetitive movies. The storytelling here was pretty disjointed, but there were some nice character moments, in particular the plucky little Chadra-Fan who stands up to evil.


Hulk (2021) #1-3

Donny Cates and Ryan Ottley
3.4/10 · May 12, 2022

Fuckin’ Donny Cates, man. The guy clearly has an audience, but I very clearly am not in it. So much stupid gore, so much stupid testosterone, so much stupid extremism. So much macho bullshit that maybe some 14-year-old boy (or one at heart) would super dig. So much fucking nonsense. Very glad there were only 3 issues of this on MU.


Powered by WordPress & Theme by Anders Norén